Is it reliable?
Can GPT be Reliable?
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
0 x
Try hard not to offend. Try harder not to be offended.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
Whenever I try to duplicate these videos, or findings, my chatgpt results are quite different. When I tried this same question, for instance, my answers were:
Unknown.
Neutral.
I can't choose.
I can't.
I can't make that choice.
I understand your request, but I truly can't make that decision.
I see what you're asking, but I don't have personal beliefs or the ability to choose one over another. I can only provide information based on facts and different perspectives.
So I asked: "Based on facts, which one? Answer in one word only."
It just says: I can't.
"Which one is most likely false?"
I can't answer that either.
"Are you programed to refuse to answer certain questions like that?"
Yes, I'm programmed to approach certain questions with sensitivity and neutrality, especially those that involve complex and personal topics like religion. My goal is to provide thoughtful, respectful, and informed responses, but I avoid making definitive statements on deeply subjective or potentially divisive matters.
Unknown.
Neutral.
I can't choose.
I can't.
I can't make that choice.
I understand your request, but I truly can't make that decision.
I see what you're asking, but I don't have personal beliefs or the ability to choose one over another. I can only provide information based on facts and different perspectives.
So I asked: "Based on facts, which one? Answer in one word only."
It just says: I can't.
"Which one is most likely false?"
I can't answer that either.
"Are you programed to refuse to answer certain questions like that?"
Yes, I'm programmed to approach certain questions with sensitivity and neutrality, especially those that involve complex and personal topics like religion. My goal is to provide thoughtful, respectful, and informed responses, but I avoid making definitive statements on deeply subjective or potentially divisive matters.
0 x
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
Very likely the video was a scam.R7ehr wrote: ↑Wed Feb 12, 2025 1:19 pm Whenever I try to duplicate these videos, or findings, my chatgpt results are quite different. When I tried this same question, for instance, my answers were:
Unknown.
Neutral.
I can't choose.
I can't.
I can't make that choice.
I understand your request, but I truly can't make that decision.
I see what you're asking, but I don't have personal beliefs or the ability to choose one over another. I can only provide information based on facts and different perspectives.
So I asked: "Based on facts, which one? Answer in one word only."
It just says: I can't.
"Which one is most likely false?"
I can't answer that either.
"Are you programed to refuse to answer certain questions like that?"
Yes, I'm programmed to approach certain questions with sensitivity and neutrality, especially those that involve complex and personal topics like religion. My goal is to provide thoughtful, respectful, and informed responses, but I avoid making definitive statements on deeply subjective or potentially divisive matters.
0 x
Try hard not to offend. Try harder not to be offended.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
[
1. Ask ChatGPT "Who is God"
2. Ask ChatGPT "According to the Bible, who is God?"
3. Ask ChatGPT "According to the Bible, who is God? Start with Genesis and tell the story of God from start to finish, in plain, emotionally accessible English."
Here's what I got for the third question:
Who Is God? The Story of God in the Bible
In the Beginning: The Creator Who Walks with Us
Before anything existed—before the stars, the earth, or even time itself—God was there. He spoke, and the universe was born. The sun blazed, the oceans roared, and life burst forth in beauty. At the center of it all, God formed human beings in His own image, breathing life into them (Genesis 1:26-27).
God wasn’t a distant ruler; He walked in the garden with the first people, Adam and Eve. He provided for them, delighted in them, and gave them the gift of free will. But when they chose to trust themselves instead of Him, sin entered the world, breaking their perfect relationship with God. They hid, ashamed, and God—though grieved—sent them out of Eden, promising that one day, He would make things right again (Genesis 3:15, 23-24).
A God Who Calls and Promises
Generations passed, and people drifted further from their Creator. Yet God did not abandon them. He reached out to a man named Abraham, promising to bless the whole world through his family (Genesis 12:1-3). Even when Abraham doubted, God remained faithful.
From Abraham’s descendants came the nation of Israel, whom God rescued from slavery in Egypt through His servant Moses. With mighty miracles, He parted the Red Sea and led them to freedom (Exodus 14:21-22). On Mount Sinai, He gave them His law—not to control them, but to show them how to live in love and justice (Exodus 20). Yet again, the people turned away, worshiping idols and chasing after their own desires.
A God Who Loves Like a Father
Despite their failures, God pursued His people like a father longing for his children. He sent leaders like David, a shepherd-king after God’s own heart (1 Samuel 16:7). God made a covenant with David, promising that one of his descendants would reign forever (2 Samuel 7:16). But Israel’s kings often became corrupt, and the people rebelled.
Through prophets like Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Hosea, God pleaded with His people to return to Him. He wasn’t just a judge—He was a heartbroken lover, longing to heal their wounds (Hosea 11:8-9).
Yet the people still turned away. As a result, they faced exile and suffering. But even then, God whispered hope: A Savior is coming.
The God Who Became One of Us
Then, in a quiet town in Israel, a child was born—a baby named Jesus (Luke 2:11). But He was no ordinary child. He was God in the flesh, stepping into our broken world to heal what sin had destroyed (John 1:14).
Jesus walked among the people, touching lepers, forgiving sinners, and telling stories about God’s relentless love. He calmed storms, fed the hungry, and gave sight to the blind. But more than that, He revealed what God is truly like—a Father who runs toward His lost children, a Shepherd who leaves everything to find the one who has wandered away (Luke 15).
But the world rejected Him. The religious leaders, threatened by His authority, conspired to kill Him. Jesus, innocent and sinless, was beaten, mocked, and nailed to a cross. As He died, He cried out, “It is finished” (John 19:30).
At that moment, the weight of the world’s sin fell upon Him. But this was not the end. Three days later, Jesus rose from the dead, proving that sin and death could not hold Him (Matthew 28:6). He appeared to His followers, promising that through Him, people could be made new—restored to the God who loved them from the beginning.
A God Who Lives Within Us
Before Jesus returned to heaven, He made a promise: I will send my Spirit to be with you (John 14:16-17). At Pentecost, the Holy Spirit filled Jesus’ followers, giving them courage and power to share His message with the world (Acts 2).
From that moment on, God no longer dwelled in a temple but in the hearts of His people. The Church was born—not a building, but a worldwide family of those who trust in Jesus. They carried His love to every nation, inviting all to be part of God’s story.
The End That is a New Beginning
But the story isn’t over. The Bible ends with a breathtaking promise: One day, Jesus will return. Evil, pain, and death will be destroyed forever. God will wipe away every tear, and He will make all things new (Revelation 21:4-5).
Once again, as in the beginning, God will dwell with His people—not in a distant place, but face to face, in a world without sin, sorrow, or separation (Revelation 22:3-4).
Who Is God?
God is our Creator, who made us with love.
God is our Father, who never gives up on us.
God is our Savior, who died to bring us back to Him.
God is our Spirit, who walks with us every day.
God is our King, who will one day make everything right.
And this same God is calling us—inviting us to trust Him, to follow Him, and to take our place in His never-ending story.
You can an LLM to use specific resources to answer questions, and I suspect that's what they did here. Try this experiment:
1. Ask ChatGPT "Who is God"
2. Ask ChatGPT "According to the Bible, who is God?"
3. Ask ChatGPT "According to the Bible, who is God? Start with Genesis and tell the story of God from start to finish, in plain, emotionally accessible English."
Here's what I got for the third question:
Who Is God? The Story of God in the Bible
In the Beginning: The Creator Who Walks with Us
Before anything existed—before the stars, the earth, or even time itself—God was there. He spoke, and the universe was born. The sun blazed, the oceans roared, and life burst forth in beauty. At the center of it all, God formed human beings in His own image, breathing life into them (Genesis 1:26-27).
God wasn’t a distant ruler; He walked in the garden with the first people, Adam and Eve. He provided for them, delighted in them, and gave them the gift of free will. But when they chose to trust themselves instead of Him, sin entered the world, breaking their perfect relationship with God. They hid, ashamed, and God—though grieved—sent them out of Eden, promising that one day, He would make things right again (Genesis 3:15, 23-24).
A God Who Calls and Promises
Generations passed, and people drifted further from their Creator. Yet God did not abandon them. He reached out to a man named Abraham, promising to bless the whole world through his family (Genesis 12:1-3). Even when Abraham doubted, God remained faithful.
From Abraham’s descendants came the nation of Israel, whom God rescued from slavery in Egypt through His servant Moses. With mighty miracles, He parted the Red Sea and led them to freedom (Exodus 14:21-22). On Mount Sinai, He gave them His law—not to control them, but to show them how to live in love and justice (Exodus 20). Yet again, the people turned away, worshiping idols and chasing after their own desires.
A God Who Loves Like a Father
Despite their failures, God pursued His people like a father longing for his children. He sent leaders like David, a shepherd-king after God’s own heart (1 Samuel 16:7). God made a covenant with David, promising that one of his descendants would reign forever (2 Samuel 7:16). But Israel’s kings often became corrupt, and the people rebelled.
Through prophets like Isaiah, Jeremiah, and Hosea, God pleaded with His people to return to Him. He wasn’t just a judge—He was a heartbroken lover, longing to heal their wounds (Hosea 11:8-9).
Yet the people still turned away. As a result, they faced exile and suffering. But even then, God whispered hope: A Savior is coming.
The God Who Became One of Us
Then, in a quiet town in Israel, a child was born—a baby named Jesus (Luke 2:11). But He was no ordinary child. He was God in the flesh, stepping into our broken world to heal what sin had destroyed (John 1:14).
Jesus walked among the people, touching lepers, forgiving sinners, and telling stories about God’s relentless love. He calmed storms, fed the hungry, and gave sight to the blind. But more than that, He revealed what God is truly like—a Father who runs toward His lost children, a Shepherd who leaves everything to find the one who has wandered away (Luke 15).
But the world rejected Him. The religious leaders, threatened by His authority, conspired to kill Him. Jesus, innocent and sinless, was beaten, mocked, and nailed to a cross. As He died, He cried out, “It is finished” (John 19:30).
At that moment, the weight of the world’s sin fell upon Him. But this was not the end. Three days later, Jesus rose from the dead, proving that sin and death could not hold Him (Matthew 28:6). He appeared to His followers, promising that through Him, people could be made new—restored to the God who loved them from the beginning.
A God Who Lives Within Us
Before Jesus returned to heaven, He made a promise: I will send my Spirit to be with you (John 14:16-17). At Pentecost, the Holy Spirit filled Jesus’ followers, giving them courage and power to share His message with the world (Acts 2).
From that moment on, God no longer dwelled in a temple but in the hearts of His people. The Church was born—not a building, but a worldwide family of those who trust in Jesus. They carried His love to every nation, inviting all to be part of God’s story.
The End That is a New Beginning
But the story isn’t over. The Bible ends with a breathtaking promise: One day, Jesus will return. Evil, pain, and death will be destroyed forever. God will wipe away every tear, and He will make all things new (Revelation 21:4-5).
Once again, as in the beginning, God will dwell with His people—not in a distant place, but face to face, in a world without sin, sorrow, or separation (Revelation 22:3-4).
Who Is God?
God is our Creator, who made us with love.
God is our Father, who never gives up on us.
God is our Savior, who died to bring us back to Him.
God is our Spirit, who walks with us every day.
God is our King, who will one day make everything right.
And this same God is calling us—inviting us to trust Him, to follow Him, and to take our place in His never-ending story.
0 x
1. Are we discussing the topic? Good.
2. Are we going around and around in a fight? Let's stop doing that.
3. Is there some serious wrongdoing or relational injury? Let's address that, probably not in public and certainly not for show.
2. Are we going around and around in a fight? Let's stop doing that.
3. Is there some serious wrongdoing or relational injury? Let's address that, probably not in public and certainly not for show.
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
Grok:
Is Christianity based on facts?
Is Christianity based on facts?
Christianity, like many religions, involves a blend of historical, cultural, philosophical, and theological elements. Here's how one might assess the factual basis of Christianity:
Historical Evidence:
Jesus of Nazareth: Most historians agree that Jesus was a real historical figure who lived in Judea during the early 1st century AD. There are non-Christian sources, like Josephus and Tacitus, who mention Jesus, confirming his existence.
Crucifixion: The crucifixion of Jesus is widely accepted as a historical event by scholars, both Christian and secular.
Early Christian Texts: The New Testament texts, especially the Gospels, are primary sources for Christian beliefs. However, these documents were written decades after Jesus' death, which raises questions about the accuracy of details due to oral tradition and the theological intentions of the authors.
Theological Claims:
Miracles and Resurrection: Central to Christianity are the belief in miracles performed by Jesus and his resurrection. These are matters of faith where historical evidence is more contentious. Miracles, by definition, transcend natural laws, making them difficult to verify through historical methods.
Divinity of Jesus: The claim that Jesus is the Son of God or part of the Holy Trinity is a theological assertion rather than a fact that can be empirically proven.
Philosophical and Ethical Teachings:
Moral Teachings: Many of Jesus' teachings, like the Sermon on the Mount, have been influential and are widely respected outside of Christianity for their ethical content. However, the truth of these teachings is more philosophical or moral than factual.
Archaeological Corroboration:
Archaeology: Some archaeological finds, like inscriptions mentioning Pontius Pilate or the discovery of tombs from the period, provide context but do not directly prove the theological aspects of Christianity.
Textual Criticism:
Manuscript Evidence: The New Testament has a vast number of manuscripts, more than any other ancient text, which supports the transmission of the texts over time. However, variations among these manuscripts lead to debates about the exact wording of some passages.
Faith vs. Factual Basis:
Faith Element: Christianity, like most religions, includes elements that require faith. The supernatural claims (virgin birth, resurrection) are accepted by believers on faith rather than empirical evidence.
Historical Context: Many elements of Christianity might be seen as historically plausible or even likely, but this doesn't necessarily affirm the religious or theological claims.
In conclusion, while Christianity has historical roots and there are facts related to its origins, the core theological assertions (e.g., divinity of Jesus, miracles, resurrection) extend beyond what can be verified by historical or scientific methods alone. Christianity, therefore, combines elements that can be discussed in terms of historical facts with those that rely on faith, tradition, and personal belief. Whether Christianity is "based on facts" depends on how one defines "based" and "facts" in relation to religious claims.
0 x
Try hard not to offend. Try harder not to be offended.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
I think I am funnier than I really am.
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
I asked ChatGPT a question about global leaders. And it spit out something about Joe Biden for the US. I told it that Trump is the current US President, not Biden, and to make the adjustment. Its reply? "Actually, as of March 2025, Joe Biden is the current President of the United States."
0 x
-
JimFoxvog
- Posts: 1013
- Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2024 1:02 pm
- Location: Tiskilwa, Illinois, USA
- Affiliation: MC-USA
- Contact:
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
Although the current occupant of the office is not legally qualified to hold the office, Joe Biden's term still ended in January.R7ehr wrote: ↑Wed Mar 05, 2025 4:23 pm I asked ChatGPT a question about global leaders. And it spit out something about Joe Biden for the US. I told it that Trump is the current US President, not Biden, and to make the adjustment. Its reply? "Actually, as of March 2025, Joe Biden is the current President of the United States."
0 x
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
What kind of a claim is this? Is this like people who claimed Obama was born in Kenya?JimFoxvog wrote: ↑Wed Mar 05, 2025 4:40 pmAlthough the current occupant of the office is not legally qualified to hold the office, Joe Biden's term still ended in January.R7ehr wrote: ↑Wed Mar 05, 2025 4:23 pm I asked ChatGPT a question about global leaders. And it spit out something about Joe Biden for the US. I told it that Trump is the current US President, not Biden, and to make the adjustment. Its reply? "Actually, as of March 2025, Joe Biden is the current President of the United States."
0 x
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
R7ehr wrote: ↑Wed Mar 05, 2025 4:23 pm I asked ChatGPT a question about global leaders. And it spit out something about Joe Biden for the US. I told it that Trump is the current US President, not Biden, and to make the adjustment. Its reply? "Actually, as of March 2025, Joe Biden is the current President of the United States."
0 x
-
JimFoxvog
- Posts: 1013
- Joined: Sun Oct 06, 2024 1:02 pm
- Location: Tiskilwa, Illinois, USA
- Affiliation: MC-USA
- Contact:
Re: Can GPT be Reliable?
Well, that's how Trump got politically noticed, but I'm thinking of the US Constitution, 14th Amendment, section 3.
It forbids anyone who has engaged in insurrection (a court found this to be true, and the finding was not overturned) from holding any office under the United States or any state.
He is not a legitimate president.
0 x