No they don’t.aussieandy wrote:God and country 'Christians' always seem to blame everything on the evil 'Marxists'. Kind of like how the Left blame everything on Nazi hate groups.
And no they don’t.
No they don’t.aussieandy wrote:God and country 'Christians' always seem to blame everything on the evil 'Marxists'. Kind of like how the Left blame everything on Nazi hate groups.
That may be, but i’m not aware of any God and country Christians on this forum. There are members i regularly read and respect. i take notice.aussieandy wrote:God and country 'Christians' always seem to blame everything on the evil 'Marxists'. Kind of like how the Left blame everything on Nazi hate groups.
It's been 20 years so I don't remember too much. I do remember thinking his predictions of the excesses of capitalism were accurate but the solutions he offered seemed undesirable.Szdfan wrote:I saw an excellent question today — how many of you armchair warriors fighting Marxism have actually read Marx?
Yeah...his analysis is spot on, his solutions utopian.barnhart wrote:It's been 20 years so I don't remember too much. I do remember thinking his predictions of the excesses of capitalism were accurate but the solutions he offered seemed undesirable.Szdfan wrote:I saw an excellent question today — how many of you armchair warriors fighting Marxism have actually read Marx?
I did in college, much of it was spent on value-pricing theory. Utility value verses supply and demand.Szdfan wrote:I saw an excellent question today — how many of you armchair warriors fighting Marxism have actually read Marx?
Quite a bit, and I appreciated most of it. His analysis of 19th century industrialisation and its problems was spot on.Szdfan wrote:I saw an excellent question today — how many of you armchair warriors fighting Marxism have actually read Marx?
Interesting. What does he have to say.Josh wrote: You get bonus points if you’ve read The Union of the Faithful with Christ, one of Marx’s works before he lost his faith.
Indeed. I read Marx, though it has been quite awhile ago. I have not read the book to which Josh referred, didn't even know it existed, but I am going to take a look. Seems it might be an interesting way of understanding Marx more deeply.Szdfan wrote:I saw an excellent question today — how many of you armchair warriors fighting Marxism have actually read Marx?
Interesting. i found this link, not sure if contents contain the entire work.Josh:
.. You get bonus points if you’ve read The Union of the Faithful with Christ, one of Marx’s works before he lost his faith.
Which ends with:Karl Marx1 wrote a devotional commentary on abiding in Christ that was based upon the fifteenth Chapter of John’s Gospel. He wrote it on August 17, 1835 when he was seventeen years old. At that time, he was attending the Trier Gymnasium and fulfilling the Gymnasium’s religious graduation requirement. What makes this devotional commentary so significant is its stark contrast to his fame and later writings.
It was during his university years that he totally rejected Christianity. He had accepted the philosophy of Hegel, Schelling, and Kant and their arguments against the proofs for the existence of God. His youthful training had left him ill-prepared for the onslaught of skepticism that he encountered during his university years.
Karl Marx traveled down the road from "Only He can save us" to "Religion is the opium of the people." 2 Yet, this road is traveled by many who have been raised in Christian families and taught in our Sunday School. The light and trendy sermons that are preached from our pulpits each Sunday morning don’t equip our youth for the university’s intellectual battleground. Sure, the congregation’s good attendance and kind words may give the pastor a sense of success.
But, let’s never forget there are youth who are being slain upon the intellectual battleground because they were not intellectually trained in their home church for the university's battlefield. As soldiers of the cross, battlefield success is the true measure of success. .. ..
This is something i’ve wondered about for years... .. The world might have been spared the ravages of communism, if he had understood the meaning and purpose of Christ's death and resurrection, the proper form of the logical proofs for God’s existence,
and the fact that Hegel, Schelling, and Kant committed logical fallacies in their critiques of theistic proofs.