Maybe it's easier to speak prophetically when it's anonymous.Dan Z wrote:It is interesting, The opinions of the Anabaptists in this poll so far are a lot different than the opinions of the Anabaptists on my Facebook feed.
POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
I didn't vote. I don't vote in elections =). No just kidding. I didn't vote for #1 or #2 because I don't see any meaningful distinction between them. And there seems to be an implicit suggestion (with which I disagree) that to be "strangers and aliens" means to not engage at all. Being strangers and aliens doesn't mean we don't confront individuals with a prophetic voice. That is where I am ... we should confront individuals and call them to be followers. Much like Paul challenged King Agrippa say. He challenged him personally. Or like John the Baptist did Herod...they didn't take the opportunity to lecture them on policy or "protest" for political policy/change.
The only solution is to reject the kingdoms and principalities of this world and invite people into another kingdom where the law is love and gospel is peace. Since Jesus is President, literally Trump (or Clinton) are not our presidents. This is the modern lingo of Jesus is Lord so that means Caesar is not Lord. In that sense the "not my president" people are right, but it is what we should be saying. Not them. He actually is there president. But neither he, nor Obama, are our presidents.
The only solution is to reject the kingdoms and principalities of this world and invite people into another kingdom where the law is love and gospel is peace. Since Jesus is President, literally Trump (or Clinton) are not our presidents. This is the modern lingo of Jesus is Lord so that means Caesar is not Lord. In that sense the "not my president" people are right, but it is what we should be saying. Not them. He actually is there president. But neither he, nor Obama, are our presidents.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
are the FB questions the same?ohio jones wrote:Maybe it's easier to speak prophetically when it's anonymous.Dan Z wrote:It is interesting, The opinions of the Anabaptists in this poll so far are a lot different than the opinions of the Anabaptists on my Facebook feed.
would you share the totals?
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
If I hear someone say "prophetically speak truth to power", 99 times out of 100 the speaker will be meaning "Call your local congressman and ask him to pass this George Soros-promoted legislation".Dan Z wrote:I understand Josh...although To me "speaking prophetically" is not driven by political ideology and pop culture causes but, rather, by Kingdom identity and the cause of Christ
Sorry for my cynicism but I spent years in that mindset where actually following Jesus, being born again, or living a holy life was completely unimportant, but all manner of social activism to try to persuade elected officials to force (for example) gay marriage or more Planned Parenthood funding was absolutely the most moral thing required - literally the only thing Jesus came to tell us to do.
I really have no desire to ever return to confusing "prophecy" with that.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
Perhaps many pilgrims and strangers do not post loudly on Facebook or choose to be strangers to Facebook.Dan Z wrote:It is interesting, The opinions of the Anabaptists in this poll so far are a lot different than the opinions of the Anabaptists on my Facebook feed.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
With some reluctance, I chose # 2 over #1. But I could go to a 2+ in the sense that I believe 'volunteering' is something that we SHOULD be doing, but I wonder if it means something different here than what I think it does.
I see "being in the world but not of it" as being fully engaged with people of the world, with no participation in the system of the world.
I see "being in the world but not of it" as being fully engaged with people of the world, with no participation in the system of the world.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
Is Facebook that place where people go to share hair-raising headlines from fake news sites in between posting pictures of themselves so that their friends can all comment on how pretty or handsome they are?Josh wrote: Perhaps many pilgrims and strangers do not post loudly on Facebook or choose to be strangers to Facebook.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
Good question Neto. I was thinking about volunteering for a political party or political cause in particular when I wrote the question - hope that helps.Neto wrote:With some reluctance, I chose # 2 over #1. But I could go to a 2+ in the sense that I believe 'volunteering' is something that we SHOULD be doing, but I wonder if it means something different here than what I think it does.
Well put!I see "being in the world but not of it" as being fully engaged with people of the world, with no participation in the system of the world.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
OK. Assuming that by involvement in a "political cause" you mean involvement in a protest or demonstration for or against some political cause or problem, then I'm pretty much in agreement with # 2, meaning to NOT be involved in that, at least in general. But I do still think that there may be certain cases where an open identification with a political concern (through some type of public display of opposition or solidarity) may be a proper way of demonstrating compassion for the persons who are victims in that scenario. I do think, however, that compassion is better demonstrated on a personal level, generally out of view of the public sphere.Dan Z wrote:Good question Neto. I was thinking about volunteering for a political party or political cause in particular when I wrote the question - hope that helps.Neto wrote:With some reluctance, I chose # 2 over #1. But I could go to a 2+ in the sense that I believe 'volunteering' is something that we SHOULD be doing, but I wonder if it means something different here than what I think it does.
0 x
Re: POLL: Relating to Power: The Christian and Politics
Well said...we are on the same page here.Neto wrote:...But I do still think that there may be certain cases where an open identification with a political concern (through some type of public display of opposition or solidarity) may be a proper way of demonstrating compassion for the persons who are victims in that scenario. I do think, however, that compassion is better demonstrated on a personal level, generally out of view of the public sphere.
As I said earlier, it seems to me that there are occasionally times when an egregious systematic injustice would compel us, as Christians, to express our individual and collective concern to political powers - especially in cases where the injustice is perpetrated against the voiceless. Abortion, genocide, war crimes against civilians, exploitation or violence against the poor or strangers in our midst are some that come to mind.
0 x