ken_sylvania wrote: ↑Thu Dec 04, 2025 5:33 pm
Valerie wrote: ↑Thu Dec 04, 2025 5:19 pm
ohio jones wrote: ↑Thu Dec 04, 2025 11:21 am
Were any of her other children there?
As recorded by
Eusebius [c.235-339]:
Most people (better nights generally excepted) have difficulty tracing their genealogy back 200 years, let alone 2000. Perhaps those who did have that connection did not consider it "something to be used for [their] own advantage" (cf. Phil. 2:5-6 HCSB).
Why wouldn’t her other children have been with her at the Cross in probably the worse time in her life? By her side, and for their brother? Where were they? Even still Jesus entrusted her to Apostle John.
I have met TWO people who claim they are ancestors of people on the Mayflower.
I can only say, to be a descendant of Mary & blood relative of Jesus would seem a big enough deal to pass on to every generation afterwards.
Whatever happened to Joseph
Right, we don't know where Joseph was on that day, do we? We don't know where Jesus' brothers and sisters were that day. Why weren't they there for their brother? We don't know that either. So considering all the things we don't know it seems weird to latch onto one possible explanation and cling to it despite having no direct evidence that it's the correct explanation.
Apparently, being a direct descendant of Adam wasn't important enough to pass on to every generation afterwards. Apparently being a direct descendant of Joseph wasn't important enough to pass on to every generation afterwards - or possibly the family line got wiped out at some point.
Wife: speaking of Adam, we only know the names of three of his sons, and none of his daughters. Same with a bunch of other people in the Bible. It doesn’t seem like all the sons are mentioned unless it’s considered important and almost nobody in the old testament had daughters if they have to be mentioned.
Basically all the men in Jesus life, other than John, ditched him at the cross. James is said to be a brother of Jesus, and I would personally think blood brother, but I don’t think it matters all that much. Even if he was a stepbrother, he would have some responsibility to his father’s widow.
I’ve been under the opinion that part of the reason John was chosen (aside from actually showing up) was because he was the one that was going to live the longest.
Although, personally, I don’t think it matters too much whether or not Mary had other children aside from some of the Mary worship some people get into.