Re: Are Plain Catholics Anabaptists?
Posted: Sun Oct 01, 2017 6:24 am
So says you J.M. but you're making accusations you may be limited in understanding of, and accountable for- I had the same list going on from the Protestant churches which caused me to look into just about everything you say here (EO doesn't have some of these things- some were by Rome alone)- and to gain understanding- these are opinions and I don't see you as 'speaking for God' Jesus is King, His Mother is Queen- you should really look into the Scripture that supports that- because it came from Scripture, and came from the understanding of King Queen relationships- It was God, who chose Mary- the "Highly Favored One" as the Angel Gabriel addressed her, to have God the Son take part of her human flesh to be the ark that carried God the Son- really the ancient explanation for her role removed the disrepspect for Jesus mother, that I find quite alarming sometimes- granted- I pursued deeper understandings rather than attack as my approach because if Jesus feels the way you do about His Mother who He gave over to Apostle John for care, then I would be quite surprised-Judas Maccabeus wrote:Oh come now. Enough of this. The church of Rome (Which may still consider me a member) is not, has never been Anabaptist.MaxPC wrote:This may be clear as mud or it may be confusing; hopefully neither.mike wrote: Regarding baptism, that is quite interesting, and something I've never heard before from a Catholic. So which is the custom of Plain Catholics - infant or adult baptism?
Regarding the Sword, I'm not referring the the just war theory, but to the use of the sword generally. Are you saying that the Vatican is re-examining the use of the sword in general, or simply re-examining the just war theory? Because, as I am sure you know, Anabaptists are not in opposition to merely a particular theory of war, but to war generally.
Re Baptism Mike, Plain Catholics follow the Catechism. We leave it up to the individual family to participate when they are ready. Our tri-partite Rite of Initiation to the Faith consists of 3 Sacraments: Baptism, First Communion and Confirmation. It occurs over a wide range of ages. Whereas the Anabaptist rite of initiation to the fellowship involves Baptism only (if I remember correctly). We have so many different ethnic cultures in our Church that our initiation rites will vary in age ranges from one region or country to the next. In the Plain Catholic charism we have families from different ethnicities because of that diversity. The Catechism is universal to our faith. Charisms are expressions of that faith. Baptism is one part of the overall great teaching of Christ in Catholic World.
Re the sword: I cannot predict where the Vatican discussion will lead. These things take prayer, discernment and many discussions. Military service is not mandated in our Church. It's not a part of our Deposit of Faith. There are Catholics who do serve in the military and there are those who do not. Again much of that stems from the cultural diversity in the larger fold.
1. They have exchanged the true Christian baptism for the "Roman Bath," which does no more than baptizing my dog, seeing as it is given without faith.
2. They have exchanged the Lord's table, for one proclaiming a phoney miracle (Transubstantiation) and claim to repeat the once for all sacrifice of Calvary.
3. They have made a mockery of the permanence of marriage, selling "Annulments" that make it like a marriage never happened. I know they may dispute the word "selling" but it is just as bad if they give them away. This is false, and defies both the Scriptures and logic.
4. They follow the leadership of one they call the "Holy Father" a blasphemous title if there ever was one. He can by the word of his mouth make something sinful acceptable. (Look up indult)
5. They call the mother of Jesus the "Queen of Heaven" "Queen Assumed Into Heaven" and even "Co-Redemptrix"
6. They willingly co-operate with the military machine, to the point of having priests serve as chaplains. If this is not an endorsement, I really don't know what is.
If this is anabaptist, I am Balthasar Hubmaier's donkey.
J.M.